| BATON ROUGE -- It's a recipe for
appalling destruction, and it could happen here:
A hurricane packing winds of 120 mph and a storm surge
that tops 17-foot levees slams into New Orleans, killing an
untold number of people and trapping half the area's
residents in attics, on rooftops and in makeshift refuges in
a variety of public and office buildings.
Parts of the city are flooded with up to 20 feet of
water, and 80 percent of the buildings in the area are
severely damaged from water and winds.
On Monday, at the outset of an eight-day tabletop
exercise, more than 250 emergency preparedness officials
from more than 50 federal, state and local agencies and
volunteer organizations began using that catastrophic
scenario -- dubbed Hurricane Pam -- to develop a recovery
plan for the 13 parishes in the New Orleans area.
The plan will provide a "bridge" between local and state
short-term evacuation and emergency response plans, and a
longer-term federal disaster response plan, said Ron
Castleman, Federal Emergency Management Agency regional
director.
Officials are focusing on six major issues they expect to
face in the aftermath of a catastrophic storm like Pam:
-- Developing an effective search-and-rescue plan to find
survivors and move them to safety.
-- Identifying short-term shelters for those who
evacuated, or those rescued in the storm's aftermath.
-- Creating housing options, including trailer or tent
villages, for the thousands likely to be left homeless for
months after the storm.
-- Removing floodwater from New Orleans, Metairie and
other bowl-like areas where levees will capture and hold
storm surge, possibly for days or weeks.
-- Disposing of the thousands of tons of debris left
behind by the storm, which will include the remains of homes
and businesses; human and animal corpses, including bodies
washed out of cemeteries; and a mix of toxic chemicals
likely to escape from businesses, industries, trucks and
rail cars in the flooded areas.
-- Recreating school systems for public and private
school students.
The ultimate dread
The Hurricane Pam scenario is the nightmare local
emergency preparedness officials dread: a hurricane that
slows as it reaches the Louisiana coast, battering much of
the area with hurricane-force winds for as much as 38 hours.
Historically, such an intense hurricane, a Category 3 like
Pam or stronger, hits somewhere in Louisiana every eight
years.
In advance of such a storm, officials expect public pleas
for evacuation to be only half successful.
In New Orleans, when evacuees from other areas who seek
shelter in the city are accounted for, only a third of the
population will leave before the storm hits, according to
the Pam scenario. That's partly a recognition of the city's
poor population: As many as 100,000 live in households in
which no one owns a car, officials say.
FEMA spokesman David Passey hesitated before answering a
question about how many people could die in such a storm.
"We would see casualties not seen in the United States in
the last century," he said.
Two years ago, officials with the American Red Cross
estimated that the death toll from a catastrophic hurricane
in the New Orleans area could be between 25,000 and 100,000,
which would be more than any hurricane in the U.S. has
caused.
Walt Zileski, warning coordination meteorologist for the
National Weather Service's Southern Region headquarters in
Fort Worth, Texas, said Hurricane Pam was fashioned after
Hurricane Georges, which in 1998 turned east only hours
before it would have followed the path chosen for Pam.
Funneled floodwaters
Flooding caused by storm surge would cover an area
stretching from lower Plaquemines Parish to the middle of
St. Tammany Parish, Ponchatoula in Livingston Parish, and
parts of Ascension Parish.
The water would be high enough in parts of New Orleans to
top 17-foot levees, including some along Lake Pontchartrain
and the Mississippi River-Gulf Outlet, Zileski said. Some of
the water pushed into Lake Pontchartrain would flow through
a gap in the hurricane levee in St. Charles Parish, flow
across land to the Mississippi River levee and be funneled
south into Jefferson and Orleans parishes.
Sean Fontenot, chief of preparedness for the state Office
of Homeland Security and Emergency Preparedness, said as
much as 87 percent of the area's housing would be destroyed.
That would be the result of a one-two combination of
floodwaters and 120-mph winds, said Marc Levitan, director
of the Louisiana State University Hurricane Center.
"And there would be hurricane-force winds over a very
large area, all the way up to Baton Rouge and even farther
north," Levitan said.
Complicating recovery would be the long-lasting effects
of the storm, said Col. Michael Brown, deputy director of
the state emergency preparedness department.
"This particular scenario shows that Plaquemines Parish
will be out from under the effects of the storm much earlier
than people in Alexandria or New Orleans, but our ability to
respond will be reduced because you can't drive through the
effects of the storm to get there," Brown said. "So people
are going to have to prepare to sustain themselves for two
or three days before help arrives."
Floating caskets
In a room set aside for those working on a plan to return
youngsters to school as soon as possible, officials debated
where the schools might be located and who should run them.
Terry Tullier, director of the city's Office of Emergency
Preparedness and the only city official in attendance
Monday, moved among groups at the state emergency
preparedness office, State Police headquarters building and
training academy buildings, addressing various issues. He
said his staff at the city's emergency center was also
answering questions from the groups by telephone.
"What's critically important about this is that so many
different agencies, and all three levels of government are
here, all singing from the same sheet of music, so that when
we do come out with a working document, everybody will have
bought into it," Tullier said.
One stop was in the room dedicated to debris cleanup.
"We have a very old housing stock in New Orleans, what
most consider as historic," Tullier said. "But how many will
stand up to the forces of the storm is anybody's guess.
"The other concern is that we've been fighting this
Formosan termite battle," he said. "How many infested oak
trees are going to be standing in the city after 120-mph
winds?
"And the other question is, how many caskets and
carcasses are going to be floating through the streets?"
Tullier said. "Those are all aspects of debris removal. What
are we going to do with all that stuff?"
An equally thorny question is where to put people as they
wait for what could be months before it's safe to begin
rebuilding.
Evacuation stressed
Brown said his staff has tried to identify potential
sites for tent or trailer towns in areas as close as
possible to the city, but keeping everyone satisfied is
going to be a problem.
"It's going to be situation-dependent on the ground
available after such a catastrophic storm," he said. "The
bottom line is that a lot of people are going to be
inconvenienced."
For Tullier, going through the recovery exercise
reinforces his belief that New Orleans residents must
evacuate before such a storm.
"I'm always asked what's my worst nightmare, and I talk
about the generations of New Orleanians who have no
historical reference in their brain about how bad this will
be," Tullier said. "And when I preach the gospel of
evacuation, they won't take it seriously.
"Evacuation, that's such a tough decision for our
officials to make, so once they make that decision, to have
people say, 'Ah, I ain't going to go,' that scares me," he
said. |